Wednesday, October 12, 2016

Emma Read-Along Discussion: Week 1





I hate to admit this, but I am so far behind! And gasp! I really hate to admit that the first week I totally forgot about keeping up! I started out so well too! But here I am, on vacation struggling to keep up, but determined to have my 2-cent say. Sorry I'm late to the party but here goes:

Discussion Questions:

1. What are your first impressions of Mr. Knightley and his relationship with Emma? Do his words about her and his attitude toward her suggest genuine care or a sense of superiority?

I think my first impressions of Mr. Knightley are that he seems more of an older brother or even a father figure to Emma. I don't think there is a sense of superiority, maybe more of a familiarity with Emma. After all, he was 16 when she was born, almost a man. He has known her all of her life and therefore has the relationship with her to scold her, rebuke her, praise her and love her.

 2. Mr. Knightley tells Emma, "You have been no friend to Harriet Smith" (ch. 8). To what degree do you agree or disagree with this statement based on Emma's thoughts and actions?

Well I think a bit of both agreement and disagreement are in order. I really and truly think that Emma is trying to better Harriet. But it is a naïve desire on Emma's part because she does cause Harriet to think better of her social standing than what she actually is. So Emma is trying to better a friend, but really doing Harriet no favors by elevating her opinion of herself.

 3. Who is your favorite secondary character so far? (Someone besides Emma or Mr. Knightley.) What do you admire or find interesting about that character?

I'm really not seeing anyone else stand out. I think Emma's father is a whiny bore. ha! I think the sister is as well! I am definitely not a fan of Mr. Elton and as of chapter 13 I really haven't met anyone else that stands out. Maybe later someone will come along. We'll see.


 4. Which Woodhouse do you most closely match: Emma, her sister (Isabella), or her father?

I guess I would have to say Emma. I think she may be a "fixer" and I'm a fixer. I want to offer advise, fix the problem and move on to the next. I can't stand the paranoia of the father and sister and the being afraid to breathe lest they get sick with something attitude that they have. I love Emma's independence and her strength to carry on her household. I love her patience with her family. I think that she is young and thinks a lot of herself as only the young can do. Even though she has been the manager of her household for a long time there still is a lack of life experience that makes her naïve about people's temperments etc.


Favorite Quotes:


"The real evils, indeed, of Emma's situation were the power of having rather too much her own way, and a disposition to think a little too well of herself."


"But, my dear, pray do not make any more matches; they are silly things, and break up one's family circle grievously."-Mr. Woodhouse


"You will puff her up with such ideas of her own beauty, and of what she has a claim to, that, in a little while, nobody within her reach will be good enough for her. Vanity working on a weak head, produces every sort of mischief."


"One half of the world cannot understand the pleasure of the other."


Words that interested me:


Valetudinarian: A person who is unduly anxious about their health.


Yeomanry: A group of men who held and cultivated small landed estates.


Chusing: This is a alternate spelling for the word "choosing" but I stumbled for a moment when I came across it. It looks kind of neat though!


Philippics: Bitter attack of denunciation, esp. a verbal one.


This is my second time reading Emma. If you haven't read it there is still time to hop in on the read-along. Visit Amber's blog at Season's of Humility to get all of the details and the schedule.











5 comments:

  1. Julie, I hope you are having a great vacation! Definitely don't let any stress from the read-along take away from your relaxing time, okay? :)

    I'm currently really behind on this week's reading, so you're not alone!

    It's great to read your answers. :) I think that's a good point about Mr. Knightley being like an older brother in some ways, and being really familiar with her and her family - so he can say more to her and be more honest than others.

    And I love what you noted about Emma's independence and her patience with her family! Those are definitely admirable traits. :) When contrasted with her dad and sister, her independent spirit does shine!

    Those are all awesome quotes you chose! The last one is on the back of my copy of the book. :) It's a thought-provoking line...and the context is rather interesting.

    And I love that you pointed out the words that stood out to you and shared their definitions! The "chusing" one is definitely both funky and neat. ;)

    Always fun to do these read-alongs with you, Julie!

    ~Amber

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm enjoying our vacation Amber, thanks! I plug along at the reading in the evenings before bed. Big weekend plans so will probably not be able to hop over to your blog on Sunday, but will get there the beginning of the week. Thanks so much for stopping by and especially thanks for hosting the read-along!

      Delete
  2. Good post, Julie. I've fallen a little bit behind, but am getting caught back up again. It's pretty interesting to see how different the language was back then, isn't it? Even though sometimes it slows down the reading. Hope you have a great vacation!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. For some reason Emma has always been a hard book for me to read. I don't know if there is just too much dialogue I don't understand or what. I like the characters, it is just not my favorite Austen book. I do like coming across some new words to look up and learn. ha! Thanks for the vacation wishes. It is raining and I love the rain!

      Delete
  3. Oh yes! The second quote you listed! I was thinking about that one! Those are very interresting words! I am the kind of person who forgets to look these things up to it is nice that you do, and that you shared them! And nice answers!

    ReplyDelete